diff --git a/docs/legal/AGPL-VIOLATION-REPORT-ChainOpera-EN.md b/docs/legal/AGPL-VIOLATION-REPORT-ChainOpera-EN.md index 6436e0cf..7e56717d 100644 --- a/docs/legal/AGPL-VIOLATION-REPORT-ChainOpera-EN.md +++ b/docs/legal/AGPL-VIOLATION-REPORT-ChainOpera-EN.md @@ -235,19 +235,47 @@ git show 5af5c0b51773737f166eacea646e3960cee29f59:api/server.go | grep -A 50 "ha --- -## 8. Evidence List +## 8. Additional Evidence: Brand and Slogan Plagiarism + +### 8.1 Google Search Results Evidence + +![ChainOpera Google Search Evidence](./chainopera-evidence-google-search.png) + +**Screenshot Time**: December 19, 2025 07:58:29 (Time.is third-party timestamp) + +### 8.2 Key Findings + +| Evidence Item | Content | Analysis | +|---------------|---------|----------| +| **Website Description** | "The future standard for AI Trading - an open community-driven agentic trading OS" | Highly consistent with NOFX's slogan | +| **Login Page** | Displays "NoFx Logo" | Direct use of NOFX brand assets | +| **Binance Post** | "NOFX Addresses Code Usage Concerns with ChainOpera" | Publicly acknowledges code usage dispute exists | + +### 8.3 Brand Infringement Evidence + +ChainOpera's website `trading-test.chainopera.ai` Login page HTML contains **"NoFx Logo"** text, proving: + +1. ChainOpera directly used NOFX's frontend code +2. They didn't even modify brand-related text identifiers +3. This is not "independent development" or "Python rewrite" - it's direct copying + +--- + +## 9. Evidence List | # | Evidence Type | Description | Preservation Method | |---|---------------|-------------|---------------------| | 1 | Git Commit | AGPL license effective record | SHA-1: `e88f8421...` | | 2 | Git Commit | equity-history-batch creation record | SHA-1: `5af5c0b5...` | | 3 | Source Code | api/server.go lines 2542-2732 | Git repository | -| 4 | Website Screenshot | ChainOpera API response | Blockchain timestamping recommended | +| 4 | Website Screenshot | ChainOpera API response | Blockchain timestamping | | 5 | Network Request | trading-test.chainopera.ai request logs | Notarization recommended | +| 6 | Google Search | "NoFx Logo" brand infringement evidence | Screenshot + Time.is timestamp | +| 7 | Binance Post | Public acknowledgment of code dispute | Public record | --- -## 9. Conclusions +## 10. Conclusions 1. **Timeline evidence is conclusive**: The `equity-history-batch` interface was created 24 minutes after AGPL took effect; it has been protected since inception. @@ -276,7 +304,7 @@ git show 5af5c0b51773737f166eacea646e3960cee29f59:api/server.go | grep -A 50 "ha --- -## 10. Contact Information +## 11. Contact Information For any questions, please contact: diff --git a/docs/legal/AGPL-VIOLATION-REPORT-ChainOpera.md b/docs/legal/AGPL-VIOLATION-REPORT-ChainOpera.md index a6331813..fcf18eea 100644 --- a/docs/legal/AGPL-VIOLATION-REPORT-ChainOpera.md +++ b/docs/legal/AGPL-VIOLATION-REPORT-ChainOpera.md @@ -244,19 +244,47 @@ git show 5af5c0b51773737f166eacea646e3960cee29f59:api/server.go | grep -A 50 "ha --- -## 八、证据清单 +## 八、额外证据：品牌与宣传语抄袭 + +### 8.1 Google 搜索结果证据 + +![ChainOpera Google 搜索证据](./chainopera-evidence-google-search.png) + +**截图时间**：2025年12月19日 07:58:29 (Time.is 第三方时间戳) + +### 8.2 关键发现 + +| 证据项 | 内容 | 分析 | +|--------|------|------| +| **网站描述** | "The future standard for AI Trading - an open community-driven agentic trading OS" | 与 NOFX 宣传语高度一致 | +| **Login 页面** | 显示 "NoFx Logo" | 直接使用 NOFX 品牌资产 | +| **Binance 帖子** | "NOFX Addresses Code Usage Concerns with ChainOpera" | 公开承认存在代码使用争议 | + +### 8.3 品牌侵权证据 + +ChainOpera 网站 `trading-test.chainopera.ai` 的 Login 页面 HTML 中包含 **"NoFx Logo"** 字样，证明： + +1. ChainOpera 直接使用了 NOFX 的前端代码 +2. 甚至未修改品牌相关的文字标识 +3. 这不是"独立开发"或"Python 重写"，而是直接复制 + +--- + +## 九、证据清单 | # | 证据类型 | 描述 | 存证方式 | |---|----------|------|----------| | 1 | Git Commit | AGPL 许可证生效记录 | SHA-1: `e88f8421...` | | 2 | Git Commit | equity-history-batch 创建记录 | SHA-1: `5af5c0b5...` | | 3 | 源代码 | api/server.go 第 2542-2732 行 | Git 仓库 | -| 4 | 网站截图 | ChainOpera API 响应 | 建议区块链存证 | +| 4 | 网站截图 | ChainOpera API 响应 | 区块链存证 | | 5 | 网络请求 | trading-test.chainopera.ai 请求记录 | 建议公证 | +| 6 | Google 搜索 | "NoFx Logo" 品牌侵权证据 | 截图 + Time.is 时间戳 | +| 7 | Binance 帖子 | 公开承认代码争议 | 公开记录 | --- -## 九、结论 +## 十、结论 1. **时间证据确凿**：`equity-history-batch` 接口在 AGPL 生效后 24 分钟创建，从诞生起即受保护 @@ -285,7 +313,7 @@ git show 5af5c0b51773737f166eacea646e3960cee29f59:api/server.go | grep -A 50 "ha --- -## 十、联系方式 +## 十一、联系方式 如有任何问题，请联系： diff --git a/docs/legal/chainopera-evidence-google-search.png b/docs/legal/chainopera-evidence-google-search.png new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0170d1f5 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/legal/chainopera-evidence-google-search.png differ